A little interlude as I finish the first round of reviews.
I thought it would be interesting to go over my own analysis of the Céleste as well as the criteria I will be using.
My Analysis of the Céleste
Criteria
Judging will be based on four criteria: three main ones and one less significant one, along with some bonus points that may be addressed in the different categories. If not, they can be reviewed in the final spreadsheet.
EDIT: Forgot to mention that the criteria are weighted and that the rounds don't exactly relate to the final standing.
Proportions
Pretty straight forward, this category focuses on general dimensions rather than detail. Mainly, we will analyze the dimensions relative to each other, relative to the desired body type, and segment. I like using the wheel size as a guide as they’re a good visual cue and a reliable way to compare automation designs to real ones.
Identity & Detailing
Based on the previous analysis of the Céleste, cars that include – especially those that modernize or reinvent – its features will have the upper hand. On different reading levels, we’re looking for a resemblance to the original design – more or less obvious.
The second part is more about, well, details. Elements like door handles, badging, light internals, radars etc will be looked at.
Surfacing
Surfacing or the treatment of the car’s surfaces is one of my favorite aspects in car design. It involves the lines, the creases, the convex and concave curves, the reflection of light and casting of shadows, put together to form an appealing form.
This not only includes the sides, but the front and rear bumpers, the bonnet.
In Automation, reflections are particularly important and tricky to perfect – in my opinion a true showcase of skill.
Fixture-Work & Styling
More distinct than the other 3 categories – through fixture-work, we simply be looking at the skill level. Was the vision pulled off? Are there messy reflections, bad 3D use, unappealing bumps and other mishaps?
With styling on the other hand, we will basically judge the configuration / specification of the entry. The paint, wheels, trim etc.
