Holy crap that looks good!
3 Likes
excited!
if i made a chassis again now it would be way better as i recently did a couple real life racecar replicas with internals and chassis (it was the porsche 906) so i now know what i could have improved on with my final design.
1 Like
Judging is here!
Quick Disclaimer
Just a quick disclaimer, I am a strong believer in the idea that anyone can improve their skills and get better at this game, and even if your car received a lower score than others, know you can only go up from here. Remember, its just a game.
@erenwithpizza- Endurance Proto:
Total Score: (23)/30
Specific Scores
Chassis: (12)/15
- Creativity: 3.5
- Detail: 4
- Realism: 4.5
Body: (11)/15
- Creativity: 3.5
- Detail: 3.5
- Chassis Integration: 4
Overall Review:
Summary
The first overall impression of this was worrying. The lights, for example, were missing internals and there weren’t many unique features to note. The craftsmanship of the aero was pretty good, and overall, the design itself was quite realistic compared to what you’d expect to see. But while the body was slightly lacking, the chassis was quite impressive. Overall detail was well done; the pushrod suspension was well modelled, and the stressed member engine was well integrated. Fixture choice was also well played, and there are some techniques that I might even use. The turbo routing was also very well done and clean. This car is impressive in some ways and disappointing in others, but with some fine tuning on the bodywork and other small things here and there, it has a lot of potential.
@Riley- Zephorous Proton:
Total Score: (26.5)/30
Specific Scores
Chassis: (13)/15
- Creativity: 5
- Detail: 4
- Realism: 4.5
Body: (13.5)/15
- Creativity: 5
- Detail: 4
- Chassis Integration: 5
Overall Review:
Summary
Incredibly impressive. Well done and well rounded, this is a very clever interpretation of this challenge and overall a fantastic car. But enough glazing, I have to be fair after all. Compared to others, this isnt as detailed, but it is well done where it counts, as the suspension geometry is well setup and the curvature of the chassis is cleverly sculpted to not only be structural but also define a body line. All in all, this thing is fantastic, and I’m thoroughly impressed.
@The-Chowi- Montagne PX Raid:
Total Score: (25)/30
Specific Scores
Chassis: (12.5)/15
- Creativity: 4
- Detail: 4
- Realism: 4.5
Body: (12.5)/15
- Creativity: 4
- Detail: 4.5
- Chassis Integration: 4
Overall Review:
Summary
A fantastic submission; this thing is amazing. Super clever use of custom textures, and a professionally executed design that could be mistaken for the real thing. However, like anything, it is not without its faults. Despite there being a very well executed chassis under the bodywork, I feel more could be done to properly display it, as there is a lot of stuff in the way even after both clamshells are removed. The interior also annoys me, as there is almost no legroom for both the driver and passenger, and the pedals and shifter feel like an afterthought. Also, for some reason, the engine clips through the firewall severely and doesn’t line up with anything that should be connected to it. However, I must say everything else is quite well done, and overall excellent.
@Axemangt- Vetka Postitsia:
Total Score: (18)/30
Specific Scores
Chassis: (8.5)/15
- Creativity: 4
- Detail: 2.5
- Realism: 2
Body: (9.5)/15
- Creativity: 3.5
- Detail: 3.5
- Chassis Integration: 2.5
Overall Review:
Summary
Initially, I had high hopes for this thing. The pictures were well done and it looked good enough, I was excited to take a look at it. And that’s where it fell flat. Now, I won’t be too harsh here because I’m a firm believer everyone can improve their skills and make some really cool stuff, however I must be blunt; it’s rough. First off, the entire chassis is made of muffler fixtures, and there are countless other questionable choices made throughout. The driveline clips through the frame very obviously in several locations and the overall engineering is pretty clumsy. I think this had potential to be so much better, as with a significant amount of refinement this could be a really cool build, but as it is, it leaves lots to be desired. Axeman, if you’d like a further synopsis and tips to improve, feel free to send me a DM and I’m happy to help.
Final Leaderbord:
1st Place: @Riley - Zephorous Proton (26.5/30)
2nd Place: @the-chowi - Montagne PX Raid (25/30)
3rd Place: @erenwithpizza - Endurance Proto (23/30)
4th Place: @axemangt - Vetka Postitsia (18/30)
Thank you all for entering, and congratulations to @Riley for winning!
8 Likes
Nice, congrats to Riley and thanks to the host for this challenge, it was nice to get those creativity gears turning for something out of the ordinary.
3 Likes
i think the engine in the firewall was a bug, on my end it was in the right spot.
I think you read the review for the car above yours lol.
oh yeah i did lol, i admit the vetka was a very rough job and then I had much more a limited knowledge of how chassis looked and how internals fit inside them, now whenever i make chassis i actually consider where the internals are placed and why (I had to design a chassis for someone and remake a Porsche 906 in automation with full internals) safe to say if I did it again the job would probably be way less sloppy and i would be more considerate when placing my internals.
1 Like