CSR 172 - Personal Shopper (Winner Announced, FINISHED)

Previous Round

CSR 172 - Personal Shopper

by @vero94773 and @GetWrekt01

Eastern Oregon, Present Day

I’m considering a new car purchase in the future once I earn my medical assistant credential and put together a down payment, and in the spirit of that I’ve decided to use myself as the character in CSR this go around. I’m looking for something handsomely styled, luxurious, comfortable, reasonably quick and nice to drive, and somewhat fuel efficient as my personal commute would be 100+ miles round trip/4 to 500 miles a week. I also need something with 4 doors and a reasonably large trunk/rear cargo area, as I drive other people reasonably often, and I do all of the grocery shopping in my household - but I’m not picky about the specific body style. Additionally, all of the cars that I would be considering in real life would be used/certified pre-owned, particularly between 1990 and 2020 as many of the cars I love and would own fall into that time period.


Rules

  • We will be accepting entries made in Al-Rilma/the current stable version of the game only.

  • Trim/Variant Year - 1990 to 2020.

  • $35,000 maximum adjusted price - see calculator section for more information. Additionally, you must include your adjusted price somewhere in the ad that you post to the challenge thread.

  • Body style is free, but it must have 4 doors minimum.

  • Wheelbase between 2.7m and 3.2m, standard rounding rules (+/- 0.05m) apply.

  • At least 5 full seats (2 front, 3 rear) required.

  • At least standard safety minimum, ABS required on all entries and ESC required on cars 2005 and newer.

  • Radial tires are required, and must end in 5. Race tires (including semi-slicks) are not allowed. +5 tire quality maximum.

  • Any amount of positive downforce on the graph in the aerodynamics page is not allowed.

  • Superchargers will incur a $300 penalty on service costs.

  • A 3-way catalytic converter (either kind) and at least one muffler is required.

  • 95 RON/91 AKI unleaded fuel maximum. You may use a lower grade fuel, though it offers no benefit.

  • No V16s, no race parts.

  • Faux diesels are not allowed.

  • Your car must achieve WES 9.

  • Interiors are not required, and will not be judged.

  • Advanced trim settings are allowed- however, you are not allowed to make the car look like something that it isn’t using them.

  • Legacy car bodies (it should say “Legacy Car Bodies” in the mod name) are not allowed.

  • All results are final, and we reserve the right to not accept or judge an entry we deem to be off-brief or inappropriate for the challenge. This matter is not up for discussion.


Techpool

All entrants are allowed 55M in total techpool budget. This is the sum of the total car and engine techpool values, as shown in the above screenshot.

If you’ve had trouble with techpool exporting incorrectly in the past, you may include a screenshot of your techpool values in the same DM as your submission- We will then compare the in-game numbers to the numbers listed in the screenshot, and will edit them if necessary. However, if you do not send a screenshot of your techpool values and they end up incorrect- or if the values in your included screenshot are also wrong, you will be binned. Also, because it’s happened before - do not use our example as your techpool settings, it is merely an example and may not be fully optimized for your entry’s needs.

Negative techpool is not allowed.


Calculator

To ensure you’re using the calculator correctly, make sure you’re inputting values ONLY in these cells and nowhere else. And note that the gearbox selector is a dropdown menu. Be sure to copy the calculator first by selecting File > Make a copy - otherwise, you will not be able to use the calculator.

Anything outside of this is the spreadsheet doing the calculation for you, be it the cells below COMPUTE or be it the other lookup table sheets.

Failure to adhere to this basic rule, or any traces of tampering will be immediately caught as we will be running your numbers from our side anyway before judging, resulting in a prompt bin.

image

Fuel economy is input in L/100km only. If you built in MPG, convert before entering. If enough people raise issues with it, we’ll make it a drop down.

image

If you forget to factor this in, we’ll do it for you and your car will be slightly worse. It’s in your best interest to keep this in your mind.

Typo check is there as a rudimentary “too cheap” or “expensive for the budget” gatekeeper. Basically if your car is under a certain unrealistic value, or over the budget of the buyer, it’ll ask you to check your inputs.

The price provided here at the end is IS THE ADVERTISING PRICE. As the car seller, this is what you advertise your car to us on the thread with. If this is wrong, and depending on how bad the mess up is, you could receive a bin (or at least your car might not be competitive at all!). Double check your numbers before submitting.

Feel free to have a go through the formulas and see how they work. If you find any bugs or unintended behavior or have a suggestion, we’re happy to hear out.

Please be advised, that upon discovering you might realize that there’s certain stats that can be used to game the system and get a relatively good price for how good your car performs. Considering we developed the calculator, we know what those loopholes look like and will flag them. Vehicles abusing the sheet will be considered to be minmaxing and they almost always receive a bin simply because they’re nonsensical cars IRL.


Priorities

:star: :star: :star: :star:

Design

When it comes to Automation, I’ve always been a designer first and an engineer second - thus, design is very important to me, and I implore you to put real, measurable effort into it.

Realism

OOC- We’re looking for a car that could feasibly exist and that meets basic road legality (think third brake lights, functional front and rear lighting, etc). Some cheesefest entry with a little tiny engine that’s designed to focus only on one or two key stats at the expense of all the others will not be considered, and will be binned.

Drivability

As I would be driving ~400 to 500 miles a week, I want something that’s at least a little pleasurable to drive, and won’t fight me behind the wheel.

:star: :star: :star:

Practicality

I give people rides fairly often, have 2 dogs, and I do the majority of the grocery shopping for my household - so I need something that’s spacious enough to do all of those things.

OOC - We will be judging more than just the raw stat here, we’ll also be taking into account passenger and cargo figures and the physical size of the vehicle.

Prestige

I’ve only ever had fairly basic and plain vehicles, so I would like something that’s a cut above those, within reason.

Comfort

Driving so often, I want something comfortable to pass the miles in - thus, comfort is a priority.

:star: :star:

Safety

I’m a reasonably cautious driver and the usual places I drive aren’t too dangerous, but I don’t want a car that would make me the crumple zone in an accident.

Reliability

Life is too short to not own a fun car even if it isn’t the most reliable, but I don’t want a car that’s in and out of the shop every day either.

Fuel Economy

As I would be driving very often, I want a car that gets reasonable fuel economy - for reference, I currently drive a 1999 Chevy Blazer, which gets about 18 US MPG average - I don’t need something Prius level efficient, but I want something that at least matches or exceeds my current car.

Sportiness/Performance

While I’m not looking for not expecting something sports car-adept, I do want something that’s at least moderately more interesting to drive than my current car. Performance is the same story - my Blazer hits 60 in about 9 seconds and ..corners, and while I want something that improves on that, I’m not looking for anything crazy quick or crazy grippy either.

OOC - We’ll be considering not just raw sportiness, performance figures like 0-60, passing acceleration, cornering grip, etc will all be factored in as well.

:star:

Value/Purchase Price

I don’t mind getting a car that’s at my max purchase price, but if there are two or more cars that are equivalent in every measure but price, I’m more likely to choose the cheaper car.

Service Costs

I’m a compulsive saver, and I have personal relationships with mechanics where I live so they usually give me a good discount on repairs that I can’t do myself - thus, service costs aren’t a huge issue.


Inspirations

SUVs and Crossovers
90s Inspirations

Range Rover (P38)

Toyota Land Cruiser (J80)

Bentley Dominator

Mitsubishi Pajero Evolution

GMC Typhoon

2000s Inspirations

Lincoln Navigator (2nd generation)

Infiniti FX45

Cadillac SRX V8

Volvo XC90 V8

VW Touareg

Mazda CX-7

2010s/2020s Inspirations

Lincoln Aviator

Jaguar F-Pace SVR

Land Rover Defender 110

Saab 9-4X

Audi Q8

Sedans, Wagons, and Hatchbacks
90s Inspirations

Infiniti J30

Mazda 929

Audi RS2 Avant

BMW M5 (E34)

Mercedes Benz C36 AMG

Infiniti Q45

2000s Inspirations

Bentley Continental Flying Spur

BMW 335i

Mercedes E55 AMG (W212)

VW R32 (MK5)

MazdaSpeed 6

Lexus LS430

2010s/2020s Inspirations

Audi A7

Saab 9-5 Aero XWD

Chevrolet SS

Audi RS3 Sportback

Cadillac CT6

For some additional inspiration, here is a playlist of some choice tunes: Playlist


Submissions

  • Submissions will open on Thursday, October 1st, 2026 at 11:59pm PST. Until then, the rules and calculator are open to input and subject to change.

  • Submissions will then close exactly 1 month later, on Sunday, November 1st, 2026 at 11:59pm PST.

  • The naming scheme is CSR172 - (your username here) for the car model and engine family boxes. Trim and variant are free.

  • To submit, please post at least one picture of your car here in the challenge thread, then DM your .car file and optionally a screenshot of your techpool distribution to me (@vero94773) and @GetWrekt01 over the forums only. Submissions over Discord will not be accepted. Ads in the thread may be posted up to 12 hours after submissions close.


FAQ

Q - “How will cars be judged against each other if they’re all using different body styles?”

A- Cars will be compared against their most relevant rivals outside of the finals (SUVs against SUVs, sedans against sedans, etc), then in the finals we will take a holistic approach to judging and compare the finalists against each other as fairly as we can. I (vero) took a similar approach in JOC7A, which also accepted entries across multiple body styles.

Q - “Why isn’t the calculator working?”

A - Be sure to make a copy of the calculator to edit the values - the calculator directly linked to this page is locked and cannot be edited unless you make a copy.

Q - “How will judging work if cars are also from different years?”

A - Again, like with body styles, cars will be compared against their most relevant rivals outside of the finals, with each section for body styles also being divided into decades where applicable (90s sedans against 90s sedans, 2020s hatches against 2020s hatches, etc). Once we get to the finals, all finalists will be judged as holistically and as fairly as possible.

Q - “I only broke a small rule! Why are you binning me?”

A - Because rules apply to everyone, and it isn’t fair to the other entrants who did follow all of the rules for me to allow your car in just because you broke a “small” rule. All results are final, all bins are final, and it isn’t up for discussion. This will be the only time I say this.

Q - “The rules say 4-doors only, so why are there two 2-door SUVs in the inspirations?”

A - Because inspirations are just that - inspirations. I think they’re helpful design inspirations and directions even if they technically wouldn’t fit the challenge as submitted. Additionally, there weren’t any 4 door versions of those cars, so I had to make do.

Q - “The rules say body style is free, but the inspirations are only SUVs/crossovers and sedans/wagons/hatches, what’s up with that?”

A - See the above comment, but mostly the inspirations only consist of those things because it was easier to collect inspirations that I like for this challenge among those categories - that being said, nothing is stopping you from submitting a van or anything - it just has to have 4 doors minimum.


Changelog

10/4 - updated the calculator with the most recent version.

21 Likes

It makes sense that there will be era-by-era comparisons of entries based on body styles - newer cars from the same segment have an inherent stat advantage compared to older equivalents that offsets their higher as-new price.

1 Like

:robot: Christening Complete


Hello, I am calculator man

As @abg7 correctly said, the appropriate way to deal with judging in any competition that allows entries that span through multiple eras/generations is to treat the cars according to their age and the time they come from.

To fortify that logic, the calculator has been made to deterministically mimic that system. Basically depending on which era/gen your car is from, each of the core stats will influence the final selling price of your car differently. Safety in the 90s was prioritized differently than today, for example. This goes for all stats.

HOWEVER!

Just like rules deliberations, the calculator also needs time to marinade and cook before it’s fully ready. I need to know if the values that people are getting are as intended, if the numbers are being influenced correctly (not too little or vice versa), and whether there’s some edge case glitch that’ll completely tip the balancing scale.

So I need everyone to openly beta and stress test this calculator out so we can all have a nice and pleasant experience with this used car CSR round.


Also I just wanted to say that I’ve been away a while, and I’ve tried my best to make this calc robust right from the get go. But I believe it can still be further optimized. Feel free to reach out on discord or the forum DMs. I will reply in my own time.

14 Likes

so this is roughly U.S based market? (since you said miles)
like a Peugeot 508 would make less sense than a Lincoln towncar?

yes, the round is set in the US

1 Like

EDIT: I’ve been trying to advocate for different handling of insta-bins for quite some time before I ever contested an insta-bin by @vero94773, but point taken from the reactions/comments that bringing up the issue here and in the way I did was only ever going to be an unproductive re-airing of personal grievances. One of these days I will learn to hold my tongue rather than run my mouth and regret it later. It seems to be a bad habit of mine on here. @vero94773, this was not the time and place for me to bring this up, and I apologize. Good luck with the contest.

Original Post

This text will be hidden

In the increasing number of competitions that do not make every rule violation an automatic bin, or in which even binned entries get a somewhat substantive review, never have I once seen someone who did not commit a rule violation argue that they were treated unfairly because someone who broke a rule wasn’t absolutely disqualified. Nor have I seen any ruleset that says every rule violation is forgivable, that rules don’t “apply to everyone,” or that rule violations won’t be met with some sort of proportionate penalty. Nor have I seen any ruleset that suggests deliberate disregard for the rules is excusable.

I will never see the logic in punishing a minor, inadvertent rule violation by completely binning that entry, especially in a computer game competition that is supposed to be a fun break from real stresses and responsibilities. In fact, the real world is almost universally more lenient about inadvertent rule violations than a computer game contest under the insta-bin rule. That is, unless I am missing all the people who had their licenses revoked for going 5 mph over the speed limit because they broke the rules that apply to everyone, and it would be unfair to not revoke their licenses when they have broken the rules.

Since I sense this “FAQ” was basically directed at me, and since I believe I have now violated a rule by attempting to discuss something that “isn’t up for discussion,” I am going to “self-bin” from this competition. This will also be my only comment on this thread since I know you all will want to move on to the actual meat of this competition rather than go down this rabbit hole again.

I just hope this is food for thought for anyone who might host a competition in the future.

4 Likes

11 Likes

screw it i wasn’t gonna say anything but i can’t just say nothing

i will not stand here and let you continue to play a victim and continue this pointless fight - there is no challenge or competition in the world that forgives a minor rule infraction; i do not care if it is done for fun or anything else. i will not kow tow and refrain from upholding something i believe to be morally correct - in this case, binning people for breaking hard, listed rules. which regarding your bin in LSC - was exactly that. you had incorrect engine years - something that has real, tangible effects on stats across the car when rectified. this wasn’t like forgetting to put your name on the car, or forgetting to post an ad - this was a larger technical issue, and i stand behind that bin, any of my previous bins, and any bins that I may carry out in the future. why should I reward someone who couldn’t follow a simple rule when everyone else was perfectly able to? that’s what i mean when i say it isn’t fair to allow a rule breaking car through, regardless of the size of the infraction.

i think of myself as a fairly forgiving host all things considered, and i do not ask much of people in the way of rules or guidelines typically. i fervently reject the notion that i’m somehow a pickier host because i uphold people to the rules that i put in place - it isn’t illogical, it’s simply following through with my job as host. moreover, i reject the idea that i should let things slide just because entrants are doing it for fun and as a break from real responsibility - guess what, so am i! i’m under zero obligation to host challenges, but i choose to because i enjoy it, and that includes upholding the rules. the only thing i ask of those that choose to enter my challenges is that they follow the rules and do their best - if you can’t do the former, then i am within my rights as a host to not reward you with a review or “fix” your mistakes so you can continue - that falls under your purview as the entrant.

this will be my only statement on this self-serving, self-aggrandizing comment that serves little purpose other than to dredge up the past.

15 Likes

There's nothing meaningful I can add that Vero and Kookie haven't already said, so we shall move on.

Calculator Update!

The calculator has stopped undervaluing 90s and 2000s cars, especially those with good meaningful stats.

Basically it was undervaluing cars from a certain age altogether, and more so if you made a really nice one. This update makes sure that:

  • A BMW 320i is not sold for peanuts.
  • A same generation 330Ci sells for a higher, less depreciated value for being an icon and a great drivers’ car, and isn’t priced closer to the 320i.

These are examples. You can interpret them as you please.

If you think this is now Overvaluing the cars, please feel free to reach out and I’ll see what can be done.

Update 2!

There is now a metric/imperial switcher.

PAY ATTENTION: After copying the sheet at the very beginning, immediately switch to your preferred measurement unit system. Then when inputting your fuel economy, double check if it says L/100km or MPG. If you criss-cross them, the calculator can’t adjust for it.

The benefit for this is you don’t have to manually adjust your mpg readings to l/100km, and by switching you can also get your mileage in Miles instead of Kilometers.

So if you prefer i(nferior)mperial then this is for you.

Again, please please tell me if things are breaky as we want to make sure everything’s polished by the time the round opens.


Cockman Out.

9 Likes

I found that out the hard way when I entered the stats for one of my test mules for the first time - it now gives a more honest assessment.

I suspect this is for balancing reasons, to avoid giving too much grip to AWD cars (which have an inherent drivability bonus).

This doesn’t actually preclude use of functional aero fixtures - but if they’re present, the downforce levels at both axles (as shown in the downforce graph, which the aerodynamics tab shows by default) must remain no greater than zero at all speeds.

Are liftbacks allowed by any chance?

liftbacks are fine, yeah - it just has to have a minimum of 4 doors.

i have a question. when you mention “advanced trim options” does that mean the aero sliders on the aerodynamics page? this is going to be my first automation challenge and i want to make sure I’m not misunderstanding anything.

its the gear icon, it lets you adjust wheel position, suspension height, and a lot of other stuff.

if you export to beamNG be careful it can cause issues.

Happy gaming Mi Amigo

ah it’s that thing. thanks for the help.

1 Like

Submissions Open

Submissions for CSR 172 are now open. Please be sure to re-read the brief as it may have changed since it was first posted, and be sure to get the updated version of the calculator from this post as it has been revised since it was originally posted.

Countdown Timer

10 Likes

No lowballs i know what i got (my submission, obviously)

5 Likes

Calculator Update!


Same link as last time but yes, clone it once again as I’ve made some meaningful changes here and there after feedback.

  • There was a typo in a cell for a non-critical but valid stat.

  • Low reliability cars were not getting dinged/discounted hard enough depreciated value.

  • Not so much a fix but rather a precaution on my end. But the calculator assumes a car with all-around low reliability spends more time being a garage and workshop princess, and therefore is driven less. Of course! This doesn’t cover vehicles like Alfa Romeos or Maseratis which people seem to daily into oblivion somehow, but yes a simplified solution that covers the majority is better than no coverage.


Q: But Vero/Wrekt, what if my car is now high mileage or is priced dubiously low/high?

A: Unless the calculator is actively broken, like that one misinput I fixed today, or there’s some formula error, the easiest answer to your question is this: This is what you’ve made. This is your proposition to Vero for his car.

Granted, I may have to clarify that the mileage thing is mostly just flavor text, don’t worry too much about it. The mileage calculator is mostly interpreting certain stats that we will have our own interpretations to. So while it’s not exactly useless or for RP only, it is still dependent on the stats we will look at anyway. So that should give you clues as to what you should adjust.

And remember, a high mileage well maintained car is far better than a neglected low mileage car. Something we can’t judge, as nothing the game shits out as stats determines servicing frequency.

So if you’ve made a mid-mileage, relatively expensive but older car for Vero or a high mileage cheaper alternative and neither of you are blowing out the full budget, then that’s your proposition.

AKA, why choose this near budget-limit S class when you can take my relatively nice shitbox that does all of what you need along with the creature comforts you want for half?

Vice versa, Why choose this crusty JDM sedan with tech from yesterdecades when you can take this nice luxury German saloon that needs a little bit more care and investment?

The calculator will try to evaluate both archetypes and everything in between equally.


PS: Yes any early resubmitters can resubmit.

If anyone has already exported their car files, I suggest you re-clone the calc and run your stats and keep improving your car. There’s a whole-ass month left.

2 Likes

i can almost guarantee it was my car that caused this realization lmao

I haven’t even looked at your car

But yes, feel free to resubmit.

Btw, for future reference,

Double posting like this is considered bad forum etiquette here unless you’re the host, or it’s a real urgent matter.

image

Always edit with this button.

3 Likes