I have a question to ask about the safety score and how it is to be interpreted. I would like to know if it is a simple additive value or if the score is contextual to the time period.
I would like a Dev to clarify this as I’ve run into an issue which vexes me but I don’t have enough data to know if my intuition is correct.
The issue at hand is this:
The original car was a late 60’s car, with 60’s safety package, and it scored 34.8. When the car model was cloned and the model design year changed to a 2020 date and given a 2010’s safety package it scored 30.9.
Conventional logic would say the car is now less safe, by 3.9 points, but my problem with this is that a 60’s safety package is a deathtrap and is scoring well, subjectively to it’s era, whereas the lesser score of 30.8 in 2020 is objectively much safer than the nominally higher score from the 60’s.
So, are safety scores comparable from different eras, or is safety scored in context to its time period?
I’m not looking to change the results of the competition or claim I’ve been wronged. I want to resolve my ignorance of how this stat works so that I can dispel my internal conflict over the results; if its a simple score I legit fucked up, if it’s contextual then future competitions will become fairer and I can finally relax, hahaha!
I think the scores should be able to be compared directly. The question is why the new car scores worse. To understand it, it would help if you posted the detailed stats screen for the safety stat for both cars. Then we can see where the car really got worse or if there’s a bug at some point.
I am not in the position to explain this, but one thing that I have felt sometimes is that the level of safety affects a little bit too much, and the age not enough to be accurate. You can get quite high scores on an old car by giving it “advanced” safety, but in, say, the 60s, that was hardly much more than seatbelts, a padded dashboard and maybe, in the best possible case, a collapsible steering column, all of them seen as basic requirements for a really long time now.
I don’t have scientific proof for this, I have just had the feeling sometimes.
Hopefully this will help shed some light on the issue, however I agree with Knugcab that safety in different eras are unable to be directly compared so if the safety stat is meant to allow comparison with different eras then it massively undervalues modern safety technology, hahaha!!!