[LHC] - Letara History Challenge - Rd 5 [Results being posted]



Entries are now closed!

Thank you all who have submitted. This is truly a spectacular field and participation has exceeded my expectations. In total there are 33 participants and 115 cars.
save me



Rd. 1 RESULTS

Chapter 1: politics, economy, and natural environment




Economy and natural disasters 1946-1954.



POLITICS

International: In 1946 Letara was still at odds with Montelin over their occupation of part of the Letaran peninsula. Over the next six years, and despite international condemnation, Montelin continued its presence and threatened the integrity of the established DMZ between the occupied area and Letara. This conflict continued to put a strain on Letara’s resources; Letara had to keep and maintain a sizable military as a deterrent, and Letara also had to maintain a large intelligence and secret service force to counter Montelin’s attempts to infiltrate Letara. Partly due to global economic woes that hit Montelin pretty hard, and Letara’s success with its anti-espionage campaign started in 1948, Montelin’s grasp on the occupied lands was starting to weaken in the early 50s… Letara has maintained a solid alliance with its neighbour Somunds throughout this era. Somunds is not only a valuable military ally, but a strong trading partner and has provided much needed economic and disaster-relief aid when needed. Somunds’ attitude is not just altruistic of course: they are themselves at odds with Montelin, so a secure and strong Letaran peninsula keeps Montelin far away from Somunds’ borders.

Domestic: The democracy in Letara was established in 1893 and holds elections every five years. Over the first five decades of democratic rule a strong multi-party system has developed and coalitions between several parties are usually required to form government. During this period two elections took place: 1948 and 1953. The incumbent government has been successful in rebuilding the economy in the early 1940s from a major slump and get the fledgling bauxite industry off the ground. This was aided by a stable global economy and heavy government investment in Letara. Despite the small economic setback in 1947-'48, the people had confidence in their government to keep the upward trend going as Letara entered the 1948 elections. Thus, the people re-elected the government for another mandate, focused on heavy government spending. In the following years, however, several factors contributed to erosion of trust (e.g., the declining economy, mismanagement of disaster responses, strong coalitions forming “on the other side of the aisle”). As a consequence, in 1953 the government was replaced by a different coalition focused on austerity.

RP effects: The government will have a pretty large spending budget (spending tokens) - these will be added to the pool of tokens the car companies collectively spend during Rd. 2 Preface. The gov’t spending priorities may or may not augment company spending, and (until 1953) will focus on large-scale infrastructure projects.


ECONOMY

The economy of Letara was reeling from a slump in the early 40s and had mostly recovered by 1947. Unfortunately, after 1947 the economy started a slow nosedive again, which continued until 1954.This economic slump was due to several interconnected factors. One factor was the over-spending on Letara’s military, secret and intelligence services. It simply was not a sustainable model for the size of Letara’s economy. The second major reason was the unfortunate occurrence of several natural disasters (see more on that in the section below). These events damaged a lot of Letara’s infrastructure (including new infrastructure recently build) and industries. The damage to Letara’s economy was huge and restoration work will take a large toll for several years.

RP effects: In the late 40s people were relatively optimistic with the economy recovering, and were willing to spend a little more on luxury items. However, after the shock of 1949 and the slowly declining economy, people’s outlook changed over time. The gap between the “haves” and “have nots” increased. Most of the general blue collar working population became more and more cautious in their spending and trended toward more economical choices. The rich, on the other hand, still maintained their lavish lifestyles…


NATURAL ENVIRONMENT

The natural environment certainly wasn’t quiet during this time! First, there was the triple misfortune of 1947. The moderate drought in itself wouldn’t have been catastrophic by itself, even though it did result in a lower crop yield that year and lowered food exports. But it also resulted in some minor fires affecting the forestry industry and costing the government due to increased firefighting operations. On top of all of this, Mt. Mordred had some rumbles and a minor eruption, causing some minor damage locally and setting more forests on fire around the volcano. None of these would’ve been disastrous by themselves, but the three natural disasters taken together, they were enough to send the economy of Letara into a downward trend. The damage was repaired quickly and the economy started to even out, but then in 1949 a catastrophic Earthquake shook the peninsula, destroying many older buildings across the country and damaging infrastructure. This disaster further exacerbated the downward spiral of the economy, it was getting too much to deal with. And then 1951… the year known as the “big burn”. As it turns out, the 1947 fires were just a minor inconvenience in comparison to what occurred in 1951. Mt. Mordred erupted again, this time it was a moderate eruption - enough to set the forest around the volcano ablaze. The out-of-control fires were fueled by accumulated dead vegetation, which was later attributed to years of forestry mismanagement. This was resulted in the virtual immediate destruction of Letara’s forestry industry and prevented any economic rebound in the short term.

RP effects: Aside from the economic impacts, the forestry industry is more or less destroyed in 1951, and will need major investment if it is to be rebuilt. The earthquake of 1949 caused widespread damage to buildings and infrastructure, so both need major investment to be rebuilt and maintained - and even more to be expanded and improved.


Car reviews and other results to follow shortly!



21 Likes



Rd. 1 RESULTS

Chapter 2: Portunis Cannonball Run 1946-1948


1946

The highly anticipated inaugural Portunis Cannonball Run of 1946 started a little subdued. The hopeful teams arrived in Somunds for scrutineering a few days before the race was due to start. Crowds were slowly gathering in the hopes of glancing the race cars and get autographs from the drivers. Otherwise festivities were not due to start until the teams were officially announces.

Six manufacturers submitted their bid to enter their cars in the race: Mons, Minerva, Aero, Vizzuri, Ainsworth, and Daniloski.


From left to right: Mons, Minerva, Aero, Vizzuri, Ainsworth, Daniloski.

First up: scrutineering to make sure that the cars are legal. Unfortunately, one of the entries was found to be in breach of regulations: the Daniloski was too expensive. Not just a little either, but a whopping $2300 over budget. This meant that the smiling blue car was not allowed to partake in the race. This left the field with five manufacturers - 15 cars at the starting line.

Before the race the organizers published car specifications, which led to widespread speculation (and betting) among the spectators. Which car will win? Powered by a large 4.7L 204 HP V8, the Vizzuri shows amazing straight line speed, but falters in cornering. It will certainly struggle in the more twisty second stage. Despite this shortcoming, its speed is just overwhelming in a straight line, and is anticipated to be able to overcome its handling issues.
The Mons and Minerva are roughly even on overall pace, but in different areas. Powered by a large 5.7L 210 HP V8, the Minerva edges out the Mons (2.4L 112 HP B4) in straight-line speed, but it too struggles to get around bends. The Mons beats both the Minerva and Vizzuri in the more twisty areas, but falls a little behind due to its lower top speed. Reliability of these three cars is roughly on par with each other - not stellar, but acceptable for the time period.
The Ainsworth is a little slower in a straight line than the previous cars with its 2.1L 116 HP I6, and also falls behind a little in the twisties. Overall, though, it is not far behind the Mons and Minerva in raw pace. The real Achilles heel of the Ainsworth is its miserable reliability. It will be lucky to finish the race!
Last, but not least is the cute little Aero. It’s small, and it’s not fast. But, with its 30 HP engine it barely reaches 100 km/h, so what did we expect? At least it is quite reliable, and very very affordable. Perhaps this car is actually within reach of most Letarans - so perhaps this is the ideal sports car for the masses?

Break-downs, malfuntions, and headaches:

Stage one saw immediate drama with two of the Ainsworth teams suffering terminal failures - and so the race lost the Ainsworth Factory Team and the Ainsworth Rally Team. Also in the first stage the Mons Titans team lost some time due to a minor technical problem, but managed to continue.

Stage two saw one more DNF: Vizzuri’s Highway Outlaws broke down and could not resume the race. Other than this, the Mons Titans overcame another minor techical issue, and Aero’s Official Aero Company Racing Team (Car 2) and Vizzuri’s V8 Magnifique suffered major issues losing them a lot of time.

Stage three was a rather mundane affair; only the Mons Paragons had a moderately severe malfunction, which set them back quite a bit, but managed to continue.

Race results:


Group shot of the winners of the inaugural Portunis Cannonball Run taken on the porch of Portunis’ most famous winery overlooking the ocean.

Surprisingly, 12 out of the 15 teams made it to the finish line! This is a remarkable success for the inaugural race. The organizers were delighted with the fan turnout too - people lined the roads all along the race’s route. With the economy seemingly in an uptick, many more successful years of racing are predicted. Now, let that Fronaco Secco flow!


1947

In its second year, the Portunis Cannonball Run didn’t see any new entries, so racing continued with the same five teams from 1946. The diverse podium of the previous year has shown that outright pace is not everything: to win, you have to finish first (and finish without any major mishaps along the way). Despite the persistent heat and dry conditions, the fans were out in full force again and crowded the side of the race route from starting line to the finish line. The teams were also in good spirits and set off for the race in high hopes of more great results…

Break-downs, malfuntions, and headaches:

1947 could not have started any more different from 1946… Right in the first stage four teams suffered terminal malfunctions and had to abandon the race: Mons Maruders, Vizzuri V8 Magnifique, Ainsworth Factory Team, and Ainsworth Racing Team. It looks like that Ainsworth’s miserable reliability is really taking a toll on them this time around.

The Ainsworth misery continued in stage two, where they lost their final team, the Rally Team, to a terminal failure. Not to be outdone, Minerva’s The Hope of Altherys and Mons’ Titans were also lost in this stage. Thus, by the end of stage two, the 1947 edition of the Cannonball Run was already down seven cars! Perhaps the successes gained last year were the fluke, or was it back luck this year? The speculation started among the teams and the crowds… Oh, and almost unnoticed was that Minerva’s The Spirit of Crugandr team also suffered a minor issue, but they only lost minimal time and this event was overshadowed by all the retirements.

In the last stage, one more car would succumb to the stress of racing: Vizzuri’s Highway Outlaws never made the finish line. The other unlucky team was Mons’ Paragons, who suffered a major break-down losing them much time, but at least they could get going again and make the finish.

Race results:

With only a tiny field of 7 cars making it to the finish line, this was truly a race of attrition. The only manufacturer in the two years of racing who had all of their teams finish the race is Aero - so although they are not necessarily fast, we must congratulate them on this achievement! Letarans are starting to talk about hares and turtles…


1948

Four new manufacturers submitted their bids to join the Portunis Cannonball Run: Liberty, Mocabey, Capable, and Mitsushita.


From left to right: Liberty, Mocabey, Capable, and Matsushita.

As always the new teams had to undergo scrutineering by the judges. Liberty and Mocabey were found to be in compliance with all rules and regulations, but unfortunately Capable and Matsushita had to be excluded from the race. The reasons on the official scrutineering forms read: “The company Capable is found to be in violation of the Traffic Act of Letara. The offence involves the mounting of experimental and potentially dangerous tires to their vehicle. Upon close inspection, these tires are found to be impossibly wide for their height, thus potentially causing dangerous blow-outs.” and “The company Matsushita is found to be in violation of the financial regulations of the Portunis Cannonball Run”. Thus, only Liberty and Macabey joined the starting grid, bringing the total field up to 21 cars.

Luckily, the volcanic eruption at the end of last year didn’t affect the race route, and people were still keen to see fast race cars - especially with new teams joining the race! Perhaps this year will see a new car on the podium? So crowds still gathered along the race route to cheer on their favourite teams.

Of the two new teams on the grid, Mocabey became an instant favourite and many bets were placed on their three teams. On paper, the 3.6L 165 HP I6 made the Mocabey a rocket on wheels. It proved not only fast in a straight line, but also around corners, this combination not seen thus far from any other race car. The car lacked a little reliability, but nowhere near the Ainsworth.
The Liberty proved to be a decent car, performance wise roughly on par with the Mons and the Minerva - but having more of the Mons characteristics. Despite its 4L 176 HP V8, due to its bulk it lacked some top speed - but despite its bulk it handled quite nicely around corners. It showed Letarans that big cars can handle well… Reliability for the Liberty was not stellar however, which left the betting folk a little apprehensive to put money on a Liberty win.

Break-downs, malfuntions, and headaches:

1948 turned out to be an even bigger race of attrition than 1947! In summary…

Stage 1, terminal failures for: Minerva’s The Pride of Valraad, all three Ainsworth teams (!), and Mocabey 2. Minor and moderate break-downs for Official Aero Company Racing Team (Car 1) and Official Aero Company Racing Team (Car 2).

Stage 2, terminal failures for: Minerva’s The Hope of Altherys, Liberty Racing Team, and Mocabey 3. One moderate break down for Liberty’s Free Birds.

Stage 3, terminal failures for: Mons Marauders, Vizzuri V8 Magnifique, Libery’s Team Philly, and Mocabey 1. One major break-down for Vizzuri’s Highway Outlaws.

Race results:

In terms of number of finishers, this was thus far the roughest year. Only 9 out of the 21 teams finished the race. Congrats to those who (by chance or skill) have made it to the finish line!

This turn of events gave some Letarans pause. Was the first year the fluke, the outliner? Did the teams just get lucky then? Is this the true face of reliability in the field? Have manufacturers pushed the cars too far and they are just not reliable? Do these reliability woes translate to consumer cars? And how did Aero manage to get all their teams to the finish line every year so far?

Such thoughts started circulating in people’s minds as their eyes and ears turned to the question of reliability as a major talking point…


…to be continued…



21 Likes

Of course when I reimport the price was over by $100. :joy: I believe an update screwed up my pricing. I’m pretty sure it was $20,900 when I submitted or at least when I exported the car which was quite a few updates back. Oh well. Should’ve checked again later within the submission period right? Hopefully my car can still run in 1949 when the budget will go up by $500.

I guess that’s what I get for entering a production engine tuned to about double it’s original power… lol

I also had too expensive racing car (Daniloski in 1946 is mine)

Had contacted Cake on that matter in Discord and decision is definitive, meaning our race cars are out for this first leg of competition

At the Desks of Aetheriian Motor-Carriage Works


1946:

Hearing that the Cannonball Run had finished and that Nayeli Endavi-Rhuthan had piloted the Pride of Valraad to the finish line first, Jonathan Rallidan of Crugandr decided it’d be in his best interests to put on his finest suit, step through the World-Between-Worlds, and arrive in Letara to congratulate the winner in person.

Nayeli had been picked by her crew for the sole reason of her being small enough to fit into the car comfortably. When asked for her strategy for the race, she admitted quite bluntly, “Foot to floor on loud pedal, lift only to steer road-ship.”

Likewise, the strategy for the other two teams had been similar, just held back by a stronger self-preservation instinct compared to the battle-hardened former fighter pilot.


1947

Things did not go as well in 1947. While they had two cars on the podium, the Spirit of Crugandr driven by Roland Wardley, and the Pride of Valraad, again piloted by Nayeli Endavi-Rhuthan, neither had a stellar run.

Raja of Bittrenn had some bad luck in the Hope of Altherys when a burst tire dragged the car off of the road and sent him hurtling through the trees at a great rate of speed. He was mostly uninjured thanks to the car’s safe design, but definitely shaken up.

When asked what their strategies were, Roland Wardley admitted, “I didn’t really have one. Foot to the floor when I could, but I was keeping an eye on my gauges and backing off if they got too far into the danger zone. That, and understanding how to change tires in a hurry was a big help. I just got lucky that I didn’t end up off of the road.”

Nayeli’s response, much like last time, was “I put foot on floor. Engine make unhappy sound, I lift by half-claw-length, makes road-ship go fast. Have to try go faster next year.”


1948

This time, things went almost as badly as they could. Jonathan stared at the reports and shook his head, before asking the crews what happened.

Nayeli was the first to admit, “Engine made unhappy noises, I kept foot on floor. Started making angry noises, then big bang and no more engine. Road not downhill enough to coast.”

Raja of Bittrenn also spoke up, “Managed not to crash the car this time. But, I did mess up a gear change and that damaged the engine. About mid stage, it shut off on me, and I couldn’t get it to restart.”

Roland added his own report of, “I just tried to keep the car in one piece. Slow and steady might not win the race, but it will finish the race. You’ll notice I’m the only one of our crew, all three years in a row, to finish this race.”


Jonathan Rallidan sighed. Was racing going to be worth it? He typed up his report and sent it home to the main office.

If our sales are stronger than expected, we can attribute that to the racing teams having done a good job here. If our sales are much, much weaker than anticipated, then racing has hurt our brand image. From what I’ve seen of the economy thus far, I’m recommending a consideration of Kasivah and AMCW vehicles - Letara does not seem to have the funds to support Minerva at this time.

7 Likes

Oh you actually made me chuckle out loud - well done. Well done indeed! :rofl:

1 Like

Glad that you enjoyed it. Figured it made sense that the races would be closely watched by the home-land to see how things went.

Top 5 finish in a 30hp car. This is a way better success than I would ever have hoped for.

Out of curiosity, what are the reliability figures of the other cars so far compared to the Aero? I wanna know how much of this success really is luck vs engineering.

2 Likes

Post race Vizzuri writeup '46-'48



1946: Scuderia Vizzuri scores second place in the first ever Potrunis Cannonball Run!

With a superb & lucky drive, Scuderia Vizzuri managed to aim high and achieve second place: Dante was over the moon, and Zeno just as glad, though full of nerves again. With that podium finish, the two went off to celebrate in a nearby bar with a few fans soon chasing after!

1947: Victory for Scuderia Vizzuri in the second Cannonball Run!

Screeeeeeching to a stop, a shining blue #8 car left skinny burning lines of rubber lathered on the tarmac. Zeno soon exited, with an overwhelmed look as he excitedly dashed around in small circles near the 4700. After taking off his helmet, Dante left the car with a grin, going over to his co-driver for a celebratory well mannered handshake-hug-and pat on the back combo.

“We did it lad, first place, that’s going down in history!” Dante shouted out, before letting him go.

Zeno looked back with a smirk: “Thanks to your wild driving no less, ya maniac!”

The two would go on to pop the front clamshell, the V8 slowly cooling down from such a hard drive, as Leterian fans and reporters tried to nab the team for an interview. A local paper crew managed to get them to one side for a picture with the Vizzuri 4700 and them both.

A day later, the paper published, having the team’s thoughts and experiences: Dante would talk about how he tried his best with the car he’s built, pushing it to the limit and using his skills he has learnt as a race driver on the global scene, as well as being so glad to have gotten first, and aiming for another victory in the next yearly running.

In Zeno’s interview he spoke about navigation and notes on certain rough segments, but also promoting the performance and reliability of the Vizzuri, can’t beat free advertising! Though he would not open up about his engineering on the machine, saying it’s confidential information that stays with the brand.

1948: Two in a row for Scuderia Vizzuri!

Outstandingly the Vizzuri 4700 #8 car managed to get a second win on the trot, giving them a -currently- unbeaten record for the time being!

With a crowd of fans drawing in, the two let up their arms in joy, victorious again, they both felt amazing. After the crowds dispersed, two were photographed for the press before being interviewed again:

Dante Rizzo (Left) and Zeno Pesaro (Right) with their #8 Vizzuri 4700. (Credits to @Secrane for the image editing!)

The duo talked about their daily inspections as well as regular maintenance and oil changes to help improve their chances of a reliable car with good care taken into looking after it.

Dante touched upon getting more used to the layout of the course year by year, but still having issues improving his time.

Zeno was just happy to complete the course, noting it takes a lot of work and love of his job helping him.

The two were both proud of their achievement through commitment, glad luck was on their side to help them through to victory! Through word of mouth and the papers, it was apparent that the Vizzuri name was more common knowledge, helping push a few or more sales around perhaps…


OOC: Wow, an interesting outcome! Had no idea the Vizzuri would come out on top two years running and hopefully more!

It’s a shame the second and third Leterian public teams had difficulties, I’m wondering how much of that was RNG or the reliability due to the Scuderia VIzzuri team able to finish each time? I’m excited for more, thank you for the writeups and hosting this interesting and unique event @cake_ape !

I’m not much for in-depth roleplay, and not very skilful at it, but I’ve tried my hardest to make something I am content with! I decided not to do the other two teams, as it might be a lot more energy than I have, lol.



15 Likes

NEWS RELEASE

WOLFE MOTORS
REGINA, SK, CANADA

FOR RELEASE: Sunday papers   

REGINA, August 1949: Lewis Wolfe, President of Wolfe Motors, announced today that Wolfe Motors will be entering the Letara Portunis Canonball Run this year for the first time. All legal hurdles were overcome and the Wolfe 200/200 Edition Coupe is officially registered. This is the first official race for the brand new 200/200, aptly named because of it’s top speed of 200 km/h (editor note: about 124 miles per hours) and 200 hp (editor: Canadian ones).

“We have put a lot of pressure on the 3 teams we are sending, this is our first outing and they won’t be on the flight back if they do not win”, the head engineer at Wolfe laughed in good spirit. “Seriously, only the Vizzuri seems evenly matched with their winning streak and a 4.7L V8 compared to our 268 cid V8, but we hear that many new competitors will be entering in '49, so we welcome them all. The more data we can get, the better. We hope to cause a surprise with our acceleration performance.”

Three teams will be competing in a 200/200 - Wolfe Regina led by top test driver M. Alfred Wilton, Wolfe Saskatoon led by the engineer and amateur driver M. Lionel Gauthier, and Wolfe Moose Jaw led by M. Dennis Albert. M. Albert did a stint at Le Mans as a backup driver, so he does know his way around a car and Wolfe is lucky to have recruited him.

“Get ready to eat dust!”, said M. Wolfe in closing, smirking.

6 Likes

Your reliability is about 6-8% higher than the Mons, Minerva and Vizzuri, which are roughly even with each other. So it is quite significant.

4 Likes



Rd. 1 RESULTS

Chapter 3: “Passenger transport” - part 1


1948

The government of Letara solicited Request for Proposals from various automotive companies to aid them in their “passenger transport” problem. The RFP process proved to be a resounding success, with 16 proposals received by the deadline. In addition to the paper binders full of information, the procurement office also managed to covertly import one example of each vehicle for personal inspection. Here are the 16 vehicles under consideration:


Left to right, back row: Literman, Mocabey, Kolondra, Popas, Minerva, Swanson, P&A, VCV, Wolfe, Kessel, Liberty;
Left to right, front row: Stellar, Matsushita, Vizzuri, Mara, Cataphract.

There seems to be a healthy mix of large converted wagons, vans, and mini-busses. At first glance, none of the vehicles would raise any suspicions from passers-by, and there are even some outstanding disguises.


As usual, the RFP packages were received by the procurement department and vetted before sending it up the chain for evaluation. The procurement process is solely focused on weeding out the vehicles that don’t meet the RFP requirements. Looking through the list, most vehicles passed the initial inspection, except for two. Unfortunately, these two manufacturers had to be informed that they did not meet the government’s requirements in at least one area:

First, the Kolondra was flagged. While it is a large enough vehicle, unfortunately it only features five seats. As such, it is unsuitable for government transport. Aside from this oversight, the vehicle was very expensive - the second most expensive in the entire field for combined purchase and upkeep costs in fact. Its only saving grace is that it can reach blistering speeds, but alas, it will not be considered further.

Second, the Popas was also flagged for immediate dismissal. Although this vehicle does seat eight, it does so on bench seats in the back - and the RFP clearly requested full-size seating. This is not the only issue with the vehicle. It also sports some futuristic tires that cannot be sourced in Letara, rendering this vehicle unusable. Interestingly, while the Kolondra is the fastest vehicle, the Popas is the slowest of the entire bunch.


With the two rule breakers eliminated, the procurement office sent up the remaining 14 portfolios and sets of keys to the evaluation office. Their task is to narrow the field down to their chosen top three, which will be shared with the senior security office for their final verdict. Here are the notes prepared by the evaluation agents:

Literman: At first glance, the paint job looks perhaps a little too military. It’s overall purchase and running costs are reasonable. We really like its reinforced steel panels, that extra weight adds a lot of confidence in the car. This car is decently easy to drive and is extremely practical, and has decent off-road capabilities for the more rural areas. Speed is a bit of an issue - it barely makes 100 km/h and is slow to get going, but at least it can go around corners at a decent clip. Perhaps better for inner city transport. This car really falters in two areas however: comfort is abysmal, worse than any race car even! And reliability. It is a wonder that it even made it this far! We were so intrigued how a car can have such low reliability, so we took it apart to see for ourselves. Well, no wonder! Looks like the mechanics forgot to include the harmonic damper in the engine. That thing just rips the crank apart! Needless to say, the Literman will not be further considered.

Mocabey: The Mocabey looks like a generic passanger mini-bus, nothing special about it - just what we like to see. It is a little cheaper than the Literman and about in the middle of the pack overall cost wise. It’s a little hard to drive, but safety is decent and off-road capabilities are excellent even. It has decent reliability and about average speed and safety. This vehicle, too, though has miserable comfort and would cause all kinds of problems for our driver and security guard on long trips. It’s nice to see steel panels on the vehicle, but otherwise it’s nothing special. In terms of speed, it is very acceptable indeed. Not a bad vehicle, but just not good enough to be further considered.

Minerva: Well, this is an interesting one. There are already a few Minervas running around the country in consumer vehicle form, so at first glance it seems this one would just blend in. On the other hand, the Minervas have such a unique appearance that they still turn heads wherever they go, which is of course not exactly what we want. Next, the vehicle is expensive - quite expensive in fact. Expensive to buy and expensive to maintain. This is more of a luxury limousine than a… “passenger” transport. It is quite comfortable too despite its relatively small size - at least compared to the larger busses. It’s quite practical but hard to drive. It has good off-road capability, but safety, practicality, and reliability are only average. We did like the added safety points to this car, and the steel panels are always welcome even if they are just stock. And true to Minerva form and what we’ve already seen in the Cannonball Run, this car is fast. In a straight line, but still fast. Overall, though, the cost of this car unfortunately is prohibitive, thus we must pass on it.

Swanson: Another military looking vehicle, but this one has a clever disguise! Definitely deserves some bonus points for that, because it’s true - everyone would stay clear of a pest control van. This is a good start. Considering the stats of the vehicle, it sits in the middle of the range when it comes to overall costs. The rest of the numbers are also quite… average. Decently easy to drive, decent comfort, decent safety, decent practicality, decent utility, decent offroad, decent realiability, decent steel panels. It is just a very decent car. If you want to see the average car: this is it, all in one. Its main headlights are the decently (there is that word again) clever camouflage and the better-than-average quality materials used in its manufacturing. As such, it gets close, but it just doesn’t offer that “extra” that some others do, so the Swanson won’t be considered further.

P&A: The next on the list is the P&A. Right off the bat, it is among the more expensive vehicles on the list. Surprisingly for a mini-bus, its panels are aluminium - of standard thickness no less, which is a large safety concern. Moving past that, we see a car that is hard to drive, isn’t overly practical, has poor utility, but average off-road capability and mediocre reliability. The two shining stats for this car are its comfort, trouncing any other car by a long shot, and a really good safety score thanks to a more advanced safety package. The bus can muster a very acceptable speed, but has the worst cornering characteristic of all submissions, so it would have a hard time to out-manoeuvre anything else on four wheels. Overall we must conclude that the P&A will not be further considered in this process.

VCV: The VCV is another large wagon with hints of luxury, similar to the Minerva. But that is where the similarities end. The VCV is quite a lot cheaper - it is in fact a very reasonable price in the short and long term. And from here, the VCV resembles the Swanson a lot more in that it is… decent… in just about every aspect. It is perhaps a little less practical, but then it is a little bit more off-road worthy. It may be a little less comfortable, but is a little more reliable. And every other statistic just about slots nicely in the middle of the range. And as such, the VCV itself slots nicely into the middle of the pack. It’s not a bad car, but also lacks that little bit of shine and polish to really stand out. As such, the VCV will not be considered further.


…to be continued…



15 Likes

I would be interested in knowing what you think is the hint of luxury the VCV is showing since I was aiming at a truck based wagon somewhat similar to a Suburban but smaller. I am not saying you’re wrong, would just be interesting to hear your point of view :blush:

Oh, that comment is solely about the appearance of the VCV. In a field dominated by panel vans and mini-buses, relatively speaking compared to the others, it’s easy to look a little bit more “luxury” with a normal wagon that has a little bit of aesthetic detail and a big chrome grille. As you see, once I started to consider what’s under the skin the term “luxury” disappears very quickly :slight_smile:

2 Likes

yet another reliability hit :sadge:

Yeah, I knew the Minerva was going to be too expensive. That, and the eye-catching style meant it does tend to draw attention.

NEW YORK TIMES (Circa 1948)

EMPIRE MOTORS ACQUIRES AUSTRALIAN AUTOMANUFACTURER SMITH; CLAIMS TO BEGIN SELLING CARS INTERNATIONALLY BY 1950

American car manufacturer Empire Motors Has officially purchased Australian car manufacturer Smith after several years of debate. Within the past six years, EM’s sales have been the highest ever, and continues to increase after the war. EM’s only factory is located in Queens, New York, which gives a number of logistical advantages for selling internationally, but EM has never officially sold any car outside of the United States; claiming that there is “not enough cars being manufactured” to keep up with demand. It was originally planned to build a new factory in Philidelphia, but doing so would only provide advantages for selling products domestically or to Canada. Instead, EM bought out Smith; a company with several factories in Australia. Doing this enables EM to build more cars and sell them internationally with ease.
Having Acquired the entire company, EM plans to continue selling Smith designs in Australia until stock runs out. After that Chief executives and engineers plan to “Refresh Smith’s designs” and “Produce future EM designs” in Australia, all within two years.
Currently, EM has only sold premium and luxury Sedans and Coupes, while Smith specializes in affordable sedans and utility vehicles such as wagons and utes. If EM keeps producing Smith designs it will gain the ability to manufacture cars to other nations, with Letara being the first country to recieve cars by 1950.

4 Likes



Rd. 1 RESULTS

Chapter 4: Consumer segment 1946-1954: city cars


The first review of the state of the Letaran car market will focus on the smaller cars you’ll see on the road, generally considered city cars. Due to their small size they are considered well suited for inner city driving, but some may be comfortable enough for longer road trips too. Despite their size they are practical enough for the whole family with two rows of seating - but legroom might be a bit of an issue. Luggage space is also at a premium in this segment. As you’ll see this segment cover a wide range of budgets and tastes. And as always, car categories are a little subjective with fuzzy lines separating them, so some of these city car offerings would also fit in other categories.


CITY BUDGET


Left to right: Mara Companion 1.3SK @AndiD, ITAL Prima 80B, ITAL Prima 100B @TanksAreTryhards, and Mitsushita T-SA 1000 @conan.

In this segment you’ll find some of the smallest and cheapest (purchase price only) cars in Letara. If you’re an inner city dweller on a budget, look no further! But are they actually any good? Are they popular?

Introduced in 1947, the Mitsushita faced some tough competition in the Anhultz 1000 R1, which had been on the market for a year already, was larger, and although a little bit more expensive to buy, actually cheaper to maintain (more on the Anhultz in a later edition). However, it did undercut the city car offerings by Aero, Kolondra, and Stellar in purchase price - but lost out to Aero in long term upkeep. At this time, it was the only city car with independent rear suspension, and except for the more premium Stellar 21-80 Convertible, it was the only one with four manual gears - so it could be said that this car was a true innovator in the field. With its IRS, standard interior, slightly larger size and full size rear bench seating, it was remarkably comfortable too. Due to its slow speed it remained firmly a city dweller just like many of its brethren. In its initial year of sales the economy seemed to be on an upswing, so it was not an immediate hit, but as the economy tightened in the next few years, many Letarans appreciated the value this little car offered at the time of its release, but sales faltered a little after the release of the Ital cars…

Two rivals came on the market in 1949: the Ital Prima 80B and the Ital Prima 100B. With their dimunitive size, these cars followed in the footsteps of the Aero cars in the “micro” segment. Both the Ital cars are remarkably cheap to buy and maintain (in fact, only the Anhultz 1000 cars are cheaper in the long run than these). With their size and foldable rear bench, these are by no means comfortable, but they are very practical indeed. The 100B has a little bit more power, a little bit more pep, and is a little bit more fun to drive, and offers a little bit more advanced technology (e.g. 4-spd manual gearbox in the 100B compared to the 80B’s 3-spd box). When they were introduced in 1949 the economy started its downturn, so people were indeed looking for cheaper (cheapest) solutions, and these cars delivered. The 80B was the answer for those who lost it all… and the 100B for those who still had a little bit left, or were willing to give up a meal or two to own a slightly more capable car. As the economy continued to plummet, sales remained strong for the Ital cars through the early 1950s.

1950 saw the introduction of the cheapest city car ever on offer in Letara: the Mara Companion 1.3 SK. This car could be yours for the low low price of $9000; that is $156 cheaper than its nearest rival, the Ital 80B. You still got a remarkable amount for this price: 5 standard seats and a 1.3L engine (compared to the 0.8-1L offering in the other cars thus far discussed). It had pretty decent performance too, and was very easy to drive. Comfort was not that great, but who could be too upset about that at this price point? The Mara saw immediate high sales upon its introduction, as cash-strapped city dwellers saw an opportunity to buy were blinded by a cheap car that actually had the chops for a trip across the country. Sales were probably also bolstered by Mara’s participation in the Portunis Cannonball Run. However, sales waned and then tanked after consumers found out that this car is actually relatively expensive to maintain and the larger engine drinks more fuel on those long trips out of the city. Not everyone can afford to pretend to be in the Cannonball…


CITY STANDARD


Left to right: Aero Move Coupe, Aero Move Wagon @Edsel, Kolondra 1400 @MrdjaNikolen, Stellar 13-46 TDS, Stellar 13-46 FDS @donutsnail, Mitsushita T-SA 1500 L @conan, Swanson 112B @Ludvig, Kamaka Chief Sedan Deluxe @LS_Swapped_Rx-7, and Swanson 117GW.

Next up is a group of nine city cars that - based on their purchase price - should offer “more” than the budget cars. Let’s see how they did…

The majority of the city standard category was populated by cars released in 1946, so in essence these five defined the city car category. First we’ll look at the Aero cars, which are undoubtedly the cutest cars on Letaran roads. They have a minuscule 1.8 m wheelbase, putting the micro in micro car. With only four seats - the rear seats being jump seats to boot - these cars really embrace their small proportions. Perfect for even the tiniest parking spot in the city centres, they are ideal for zooming around the tight streets. With a top speed that doesn’t approach 100 km/h, these are true city dwellers. So with the diminutive size, basic interior, and lacklustre performance, you might ask, why are these so expensive (expensive used in a relative sense of course). Well, great care has gone into manufacturing them. They have a galvanized chassis and aluminium panels, which is a first so far. Their upkeep is cheap too, making them among the cheapest cars in the long run. And they are frankly just fun to drive, especially the Move Coupe! Despite the Aero not being comfortable, just by their sheer cuteness they attracted a small cult following. The Move Wagon saw fairly low sales because its value proposition was just not up to par with the cheaper budget offerings, but the Move Coupe, with its fun driving character sold much better, especially after the year-after-year reliability showcase put on by Aero in the Portunis Cannonball Run.

With the Kolondra we’re stepping up just a tiny bit in initial purchase price, but the upkeep costs of this car are significantly higher. This car seems to have a little bit of an identity crisis, which didn’t go unnoticed by Letarans. It has what appears to be an eco 1.4L engine with 36 HP, but it has tubular race headers (which the government immediately mandated to be swapped, raising the car’s purchase price and hassle for consumers). Then for a city car, it has an offroad skid tray, but no other offroad aspirations whatsoever - in fact the Aero cars have higher offroad capability. The build quality also seems to be a little sub-par with giant panel gaps here and there, not to mention the terrible brakes that not only don’t grip, but also send the car into a terrible spin - if they haven’t caught fire before yet. It was just a too confusing car and the mandatory header swap was a little much for many Letarans to deal with, so the Kolondra never became a strong seller.

Stepping up price a little bit more, we come to the two Stellar offerings: a two-door and a four-door trim of the same car. These cars are the cheapest city cars with a premium interior and Premium radio (these cars are the first so far with any radio); the two-door with 2/2 seating and the four-door with two benches. At this (or well… any) price point, no other car can beat these in terms of comfort - the only more comfortable offering is the third Stellar - the convertible. It is truly impressive how comfortable these cars are, even beating many larger family and premium family sedans. What is the downside you might ask? Well, upkeep isn’t exactly cheap. Still cheaper than the Kolondra, and cheaper than many other city car offerings, but not exactly cheap per se. But if you lived in Letara in the late 40s, had the little bit of extra money, and wanted to maximize your value for dollar and get the most comfortable city car at a reasonable price, you got a Stellar. Which of the two trims only depends on how big your family is. Needless to say, the Stellar flew off the shelves as middle-class city dwellers flocked to the Stellar dealership.

Stepping up a little bit in price, the next release of Mitsushita came in 1950. The T-SA 1500 L is a larger brother to the T-SA 1000. As such it is more expensive. But is it the answer Letarans were waiting for after the T-SA 1000 was overtaken by the Ital duo? Well, yes, but also no. The T-SA 1500 L is a significant step up from its predecessor. It now has a premium radio, advanced safety features, more comfortable medium compound tires. As such it is a lot more safe, and nearly as comfortable as the Stellar cars. Its overall upkeep is also on par with the Stellars. So yes, the T-SA 1500 L did eclipse the Itals, Mitsushita’s previous rival - but with the change made, the new rivals were really the Stellars. And the Mitsushita fought this fight well, but ultimately lost out a little bit. The Mitsushita still saw strong sales, but given that it offered about the same as the Stellar cars but was four years late to the party did hurt in the end.

In 1952 the two Swanson cars were introduced. These were a true novelty in the city car segment: they had unibody construction! And galvanized steel chassis. Truly groundbreaking things. Of course these advanced features came at a cost. Both of these cars were quite a bit more expensive than anything seen before. The Swanson 112B’s upkeep was at least reasonable, but the Swanson 117GW blew every car from before out of the water. Aside from the monocoque and galvanized chassis, what else did you get as a driver? Well, not much as it turns out. The 112B had a basic interior and no radio - a spartan interior space only “rivalled” by Aero. In the 117GW you at least got a standard interior and radio, but this is still vastly sub-par in this price category. Sure these cars were fairly reliable, easy to drive, and very safe, they just weren’t comfortable nor offered anything special for the increasingly cost-conscious common consumer. If you wanted to buy a comfortable car, you already had a better option in the Stellar, if you wanted that bare-bones fun to drive small car with a hint of sportiness, there was the Aero. Both much cheaper. So, especially given the economic woes of the early 1950s, the Swanson was mostly overlooked by Letarans.

Last but not least, the Kamaka Chief Sedan Deluxe was introduced in 1953. It’s always interesting to see a car introduced during a large societal and political change. It can either be a good thing as people are more hopeful for a brighter future, or a complete flop as people’s attention are on everything but making new major purchases. The Kamaka was launched into just such an environment. It came on the market as a relatively expensive offering in the city car market, but it did offer many creature comforts such as a premium interior and radio, and more comfortable medium compound tires. Despite these amenities its comfort still lagged behind the Stellars and Mitsushita. Its upkeep costs were astronomical compared to the other city cars thus far discussed. And worst of all - the car shipped with some experimental tires that were not government approved - so owners had to buy new tires before even driving off the lot! For the reasons, the Kamaka became a car that was simply never seriously considered by most Letarans.


CITY PREMIUM


Left to right: Stellar 21-80 Convertible @donutsnail, Torshalla Poesy @Maverick74, and Swanson 125 SP @Ludvig.

Now we get to the more expensive side of the city car market: the premium offerings. Arguably, some of the previous cars would fit this category in term of their features and statistics, but here price is king. So are these three cars worth the premium price?

Introduced right in 1946 along with its cheaper siblings, the Stellar 21-80 Convertible truly has a premium price tag. More expensive to purchase and a lot more expensive to maintain, this car could only be afforded by the more well-off in Letara. Luckily, in 1946 people were still optimistic about the future… So what did all this money get you? The only luxury interior in the entire city segment, a premium radio and - the only convertible in the field! This makes the Stellar 21-80 Convertible really stand out from the field. It is also the most comfortable offering in the city car segment, which is just as well at this price point. Not only was this the most comfortable city car, it was also the fastest - a little rocket on wheels with its 2.4L 6-banger engine! The fact that it only has 2/2 seating doesn’t even matter here. The “young and rich” generation, who naturally are more optimistic about the future anyway, flocked to this car like bees to honey. At least for a few years… once the economy turned, many were forced to sell their toys and look for cheaper options.

The Torshalla Poesy and the Swanson 125P were both introduced in 1952, which seems like a bad time to introduce such expensive cars. Price and upkeep-wise the Torshalla was on par with the Stellar Convertible. In contrast, it did offer a monocoque design, but it only had standard interior with standard radio. Quite a step down. The advanced safety was a nice feature, though, making it the second safest car in the city segment (only behind the Swanson 125P), but both far above the rest of the field. But one still had to wonder where all the money went, why was it so expensive? The 40 HP engine is surely not that special, and otherwise the car didn’t seem to bring anything special to the table. Unfortunately for the Torshalla, it proved to be just too expensive for what it offered, which is a dangerous proposition in a major economic downturn. It’s only saving grace is that it just looked so nice, resulting in a few sales; and these few cars have generally been well cared for and remained in good shape for many years.

Last we come to the Swanson. Now this car truly had a premium - almost luxury car - price tag. At the time of release, it was the fourth most expensive car on the entire Letaran car market, and was almost equally expensive to maintain. The monocoque galvanized chassis was surely a large factor in its exuberant price. Similar to the Stellar, this car also has a 2.4L 6-cylinder engine, this time in a boxer configuration. This car is by far the fastest of all city size cars, reaching 160 km/h and 100 km/h in 9.8 s - figures only reached by the most expensive sedans and dedicated sports cars. Despite it being a hatchback, not a conventional coupe, you could indeed claim that this is in fact a tiny sports car with its automatic locker differential (the only non-open diff in the city segment), and sport tires. Safety is best in segment, comfort is more than decent, and sportiness is unparalleled even counting true sports cars. Well, maybe that is just what it is - a tiny premium sports car. In conclusion, the Swanson offered plenty of perks for its price. If you were lucky enough to save money during the recession, were low on space or lived in the city, or just wanted a tiny car to throw around, but also wanted to blast down the straight roads pretending to drive in the Cannonball, then this was the car for you. Not many Swanson 125 SPs were sold, simply due to the smaller market for these cars, but they were extremely popular and coveted by many who could not afford one…


…to be continued…



25 Likes

Message of ITAL President, Giano De Lucchi, during the press release for the 25000th Prima sold in Letara, October 1950

Our time in Letara has been nothing short of amazing: no other country has given such a warm welcome to our cars as you Letarans. You proud people even rival the love that our own home country of Italy has reserved us, and all in two short years of ITAL presence in Letara.
I am well aware that Letara’s economy has seen some of you struggling in the wake of the growing recession, and yet here we are, with 25000 of you proud people trusting our cars in such dire times. When ITAL was founded back in 1902, our goal has always been to reach as much people as possible with our veichles, to give everyone access to cheap, reliable mobility for the everyday need of everyone.
We fully belive in a future when a car will be in every house, where distances will be shorter than ever before, and i’m proud that even today, here in Letara,we are making a step foward such a future. All thanks to you, proud Letarans, who have given us trust even in such hardship. And while it’s hardly times for celebrations, we feel we should at least give you people something to thank you.
And so, untill the end of this 1950, all our Prima 80Bs will be sold at a 100$ discount; and all our 100B and Van models will net you a 125$ discount deal. And for those of you that already own our cars, we will be happy to take care of their servicing for free, until the dawn of the new year.
I once again thank all of Letara, for having trusted us as one of your own. Might 1951 be a better year for us all!

7 Likes