The Argument for the Squad Car
Yes! I think we need a new market. What I would like to see is one which represents police squad cars/interceptors, as well as private security vehicles. I know there’s a lot of resistance to this idea and it’s been brought up before, but let me outline my argument:
What is the Squad Car?
This market would desire:
- Offroad (Needs to drive on bad roads, dirt roads, and sometimes fields or over curbs)
- Size (May need to push other cars around)
- Moderate budget
- Sedan body type, with potential for wagons and SUVs
What does this mean for the player?
These demands are fairly unique, but adjacent to several markets. In real life, police cars are usually either exactly the same as cars offered to consumers, or have minor modifications specially for that market (a variant). For example, many police cars have been offered with more robust suspension than their standard counterparts. The recent era Dodge Charger was offered to police with a V8 and AWD together, whereas normally the AWD variants were only available with the V6.
There are several large markets where players might be tempted to modify their car, or make a separate variant, towards the squad car market. Family cars are practical and tend to have better than zero offroad, but may need a better engine. Passenger Fleet vehicles are reliable and get good gas mileage above all else, also making them good candidates for an engine swap. Sport and Family Sport type cars have the power and sportiness, but might need a suspension lift and harder tires to get some offroad, as well as possibly a cheaper interior. Makers of trucks already have engines which are both large and reliable, and might find new applications for their engines. Sport Utility Premium tends to have the speed and offroad, but a variant with a cheaper interior might appeal better to the squad car market.
This market would be especially unique in that it is a market for powerful, high-performance cars, but prefers reputation and reliability over luxury and prestige, and offroad abilities must be balanced with the need for some sportiness. As an added bonus, players can already sort of make race cars by aiming for the Track market, and this provides a market which might appeal for players who want to make rally-style cars.
Where will it go on the market screen?
Yes, I know the market screen is full. It looks good the way it is and there’s no room for another rectangle.
But why the hell do we have three, separate delivery markets? In my opinion Delivery, Light Delivery, and Heavy Delivery are all far too similar to each other, and having these as separate markets doesn’t pose any interesting design challenges. Every delivery van I’ve ever made has had strong appeal to all three. I propose we eliminate Delivery, leaving only Light Delivery and Heavy Delivery. This would free up a slot for Squad Cars (or a different new market that’s appealing) and we can have some more variety in demand.
The Arguments Against the Squad Car (and Rebuttals)
It doesn’t make sense to sell police cars month to month on the open market
In my opinion, this is true of Delivery and especially Passenger Fleet as well. Who ever heard of a taxi company buying a few cars at a time instead of a lot of identical ones at once? Normally taxi services and delivery services buy lots of vehicles on contract, but in the absence of a contract system, we have them as markets in the game anyway because they have interesting requirements but often buy the same models of cars as regular consumers. I don’t think having a certain trim make 2 sales the the squad car market hurts immersion any further. Besides, police occasionally do one-offs!
The player doesn’t have vanilla fixtures for it
Obviously, players are going to wonder why they can’t put police lights and decals on the car if they’re selling it to the police. Depending on the era and location, governments often made this customizations themselves or at an aftermarket vendor. Once again looking at the Passenger Fleet market, the player doesn’t have vanilla taxi signs, decals or meters, which are characteristic at this market, so I don’t think it’s any worse than the current state of affairs.
It’s not a very big market, why build for it?
Neither is Track Premium! And that’s part of what makes it interesting… just like in real life, police have fairly different demands compared to ordinary consumers, and this is why they usually use cars which are identical or similar to those for sale to the public. In order to profitably sell to this market, it is best to create a variant of an existing model, rather than make a dedicated car for it. Depending on which markets your company is already targeting, this could take a lot of different shapes, such as a more rugged variant of your Sports car or an upgraded version of your Family car.
Police cars provide a lot of interesting decisions to the player because they have unique requirements, but are similar enough to several markets that a variant could be made. While they aren’t a huge market, they are an iconic part of many manufacturers’ lineups, and an import element of automotive history. Adding the market shouldn’t take a lot of development effort, since it doesn’t depend on any new artwork or mechanics, only changing and balance-testing existing numbers. Also, seriously, we do not need three separate delivery markets, they look like they’re just there to prevent empty space in the bottom left of the market screen- let’s get something that encourages creativity instead.